Skip to main content

A Case of Mistaken Identity

In genealogical terms, getting married means adding whole new branches to the family tree.  Of course, I was excited when my new husband told me what he knew about his family and I began researching new family lines.  Unfortunately, sometimes the thrill of the chase gets in the way of sound research practices.  Boy, did I learn my lesson!


It all started innocently enough.  I typed his grandmother’s first name and maiden name into Ancestry.com’s search engine.  Her last name is a bit unusual in the U.S.  When I found someone who had the exact same name and was about the same age living in California in the 1930 U.S. Census, I assumed I had found the right person.


Instead of confirming with my husband’s family whether or not the information was correct, I kept going, hot on a trail.  Perhaps, it was because I found this family so interesting.  The census record included four generations of women, revealing three surnames to research.  I plugged these names into the search engine and discovered a family that had moved west during the California gold rush.  Their names came up in county histories and historical newspapers from California and Nevada.


I presented what I had found to my husband.  I was proud of my research.  Research implies that a scientific approach was used.  I did no such thing.  I simply followed the click, click, click of the mouse.  It was gently pointed out to me that I was wrong.  How embarrassed I was.


One has to be careful when searching the census.  It is a great resource but also has its limits.  Accuracy is dependent on how knowledgeable the household member or neighbor was and how detailed the census taker was at the time of the census.  I eventually located my husband’s grandmother in the census.  She was living with her parents and uncle.  The family name was spelled wrong which explains why it did not pop up on my first search attempt.


I have definitely learned a lesson.  Over the years, I have developed a strong research methodology because of my experience.  Now I spend more time examining various records and evaluating potential relatives before expanding my family tree. 


 

 
Labels:
Location: Los Angeles, California, USA

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What Time Is It: The Ingersoll Watch Company

Recently, I saw a segment about Ingersoll wristwatches circa World War I on the PBS television program Antiques Roadshow . It triggered a flashback to my mother telling me that we’re related to the Ingersoll watch family. At the time, images of Bavarian forefathers living deep in the forest and building cuckoo clocks swirled in my head. Before family lore starts spinning out of control, let’s explore the real story. I can trace at least two family lines, the Bryants of Reading, Massachusetts and the Ingersolls of Long Island, New York to early colonial America, through my great-grandfather, Jerome Calvin Bryant. Jerome and his mother, Mary Ellen Ingersoll, are listed on page 494 of A Genealogy of the Ingersoll Family in America 1629-1925 , by Lillian Drake Avery (click here to view a digital version of the book at FamilySearch). Mary Ellen (Henry Jackson 6 , Henry 5 , Ezra 4 , Josiah 3 , John 2 ,John 1 ) was the seventh generation from the immigrant ancestor born in England, Joh...
Post a Comment
Read more

John Burwell Family

I found a pair of Burwell sisters in the DAR [Daughters of the American Revolution Lineage Books] that I believe are my great-great-grandfather John W. Burwell's sisters. From Volume 14, p. 122 (for the year 1896): Miss Nettie B. Burwell ID No. 13326 Born in Illinois Descendant of John Burwell, of New Jersey. Daughter of Moses T. Burwell and Isabella Goodfellow, his wife. Granddaughter of John Burwell and Missouri Thorp, his wife. Gr.-granddaughter of Jonathan Burwell and Mary Comer, his wife. Gr.-gr.-granddaughter of John Burwell and ___ Lyons, his wife. John Burwell turned out in Capt. Stephen Baldwin's company, Col. Sylvanus Seely's regiment of Morris county militia, 1780, at Connecticut Farms, N.J. He died 1825. Mrs. Mary Alice Burwell Burns ID No. 13327 Born in Illinois. Wife of Luther Burns. Descendant of John Burwell. Daughter of Moses T. Burwell and Isabella Goodfellow, his wife. See No 13326. I believe that these women are John W.'s sisters for several reasons:...
Post a Comment
Read more

Burwell House Hotel in Gibson City, Illinois (circa 1890)

GRAND OPENING OF THE BURWELL HOUSE A home thrown open to the "Boys," and the traveling public of which Gibson may justly feel proud.    A host of invited guests from home and abroad partake of a banquet at 6 p.m. this evening prepared by J. R. Lott and wife the genial host and hostess. Who will always be found pleasant people. For some months, attention of our home people and visitors from abroad has been directed to the fine brick hotel being erected by Mr. M. T. Burwell, a well-known banker, real estate broker, and wealthy citizen.    The hotel building is 26 x 160 feet, two stories high, and basement, built very completely with every convenience usual to a first class hotel, the whole structure costing about $15,000.    To-day this hotel is opened to the public by Mr. and Mrs. J. R. Lott who formerly kept the St. Nicholas in this city, and who enjoy a wide reputation for keeping a first class hotel, and a hearty patronage in the past, together with...
Post a Comment
Read more